The first thing a monastery in Spiti or west Sikkim tells you is that it is not primarily a place to pray in. It is a wall with a door in it, and behind the wall are store rooms. The temples are inside that enclosure, not the other way round: the wall comes first, the shrines are fitted into it, and the reason is that the wall is doing three jobs at once.

Section through a monastery enclosure wall, and the three income sources that succeeded one another ONE WALL, THREE JOBS grain store 0.91 m one small window, set high mud brick, no buttress poplar, brush and earth on timber joists Warmth: mass, not fuel. Storage: dry, dark, guarded. Authority: one door to watch. ONE BUILDING, THREE INCOMES rent from estates grain and labour, from tenants to 1950 land reform, 1949–51 a department a subsidy, and a record to keep 1950– roads, and visitors the gate receipts, fees, a guest house 1975– The wall did not change. The room behind it did: grain, then paper, then visitors.
The enclosure wall is a thermal device, a granary and a strongroom in one section. What changed in the twentieth century was not the building but the ledger behind it: rent from tenants, then a subsidy, then the gate.

Why the wall is thick

At Tabo, in the Spiti valley, the enclosure wall is about 0.91 metres of mud brick, running around roughly 6,300 square metres, with nine temples and twenty-three chortens inside. The site is at 3,050 metres. Winter there is not a season you dress for; it is a season you build against, and the building logic is the logic of a thermos flask rather than a temple.

Mud has high thermal mass. A wall almost a metre thick takes days to warm and days to cool, which flattens the daily swing between sun and shadow — the two things that actually hurt at altitude. A small window, set high, loses less heat and lets in light without letting in the wind that carries grit. Heating is the scarce input, so the architecture spends wall instead of fuel. This is not mysterious, and it is not specifically Buddhist: the same section appears in ordinary houses in the same valleys, for the same reasons.

The second and third jobs are less visible from outside. Behind that wall, a monastery held its grain: barley, butter, tea, and the dried food that has to last from one harvest to the next in a place where the growing season is four months. Grain needs to be dry, dark, off the ground and guarded, which is a description of a store room with one door. And a community that keeps its wealth in a strongroom needs the strongroom to be defensible, because the wealth is portable and the nearest authority may be two days' walk away.

One wall, then, answers three questions at once: how do we stay warm without fuel, where do we keep a year of food, and who can get in. That is why the windows are small. Not humility. Heat.

The monastery as landlord

In Sikkim the institution was explicit about this. Five monasteries — Pemayangtse, Ralong, Rumtek, Phodong and Phensong — held landed estates, and their heads sat on the ruler's council. An estate was run by a standing council of three officers: the dorje lopon, the buze and the discipline master, who together appointed a mandal to collect and a secretary to keep the accounts.

The tenancy arrangements are the part that makes the claim precise. Estates were worked by tenants who owed rent in kind, and in some cases by landless households holding a plot in exchange for labour service on estate land. A 1901 edict settles a boundary dispute by granting a named tract to Pemayangtse in perpetuity together with an annual subsidy, and exempts the monastery from court fees — the marks of an institution that is inside the revenue system, not beside it.

This is why "the monastery was also a government" is not a metaphor. It collected from named households, it kept books, it adjudicated, it maintained the buildings and the school out of the surplus, and it could call on the labour of people who lived on its land. Its religious authority was real; so was its rent roll, and the two supported each other. A lama with no estate still had prestige. A lama with an estate had a budget.

What land reform did to a religious institution

The decisive change was not doctrinal and it did not come from inside the monastery. Between 1949 and 1951 the tenancy system was abolished, a 1950 notification dissolved the ruler's private estates and the monastery lands, and the 1951 settlement gave property rights to cultivators who had worked a plot for fourteen years or more.

The monasteries were not simply expropriated; they were converted into a budget line. Estates passed to an ecclesiastical department, and in the case of Pemayangtse the department refunded part of the revenue it collected until the 1980s — which is exactly the shape of a transition from property income to a subsidy, and it produced exactly the disputes you would expect: claims in the 1990s for the taxes that had not been refunded, and for the right to collect directly again.

Read this as an institutional event rather than a political one. A monastery whose income came from land had an incentive to be a good landlord and a good court; that was the job. A monastery whose income comes from a department has an incentive to be legible to the department — to keep records, to qualify for schemes, to maintain a building that a conservation agency will fund. A monastery whose income comes from visitors has an incentive to be open, photogenic and scheduled.

The same wall, a different room

None of this changed the architecture, which is the interesting part. The wall is still 0.91 metres of mud. What changed is what is behind it. The grain store became a store of something else: registers, and later a ticket counter, a guest house, a school that charges fees and receives a share of its costs from the state.

Tabo is a good place to watch the seam. It was damaged by the 1975 earthquake and repaired; a new assembly hall went up in 1983; in 2002 the Archaeological Survey replaced a failing deodar beam in the main hall with sal, because deodar of that dimension could not be got. A thousand-year-old mud building now depends on a conservation agency, a festival calendar that brings visitors every third year, and a school. The building is older than all three of its current income sources, and it will probably outlast them.

The pillar's question is what had to be built and paid for before any of this could be believed in public. In the Himalaya the answer is unusually literal: a wall thick enough to hold a year's food and a day's heat, a council of three to run the estate, a tenant to work it — and, once the tenants became owners, a department to sign the cheque instead.

Sources and checks

  1. Bhutia, Gnudup Sangmo Monastic Land Holding System in Sikkim (1642–1975). PhD thesis, University of North Bengal — the estates, their revenue and their dissolution
  2. Balikci, Anna Lamas, Shamans and Ancestors: Village Religion in Sikkim. Brill, 2008 — on the monastery's role in village life
  3. SIT Study Abroad Chogyal's Sikkim: Tax, Land and Clan Politics — independent study project on the udor cheotsum council, the mandal and the 1901 edict
  4. Archaeological Survey of India Tabo: A World Heritage Site in the Himalaya — conservation reports on the mud-brick complex, the 1975 earthquake damage and the 2002 beam replacement
  5. Klimburg-Salter, Deborah E. Tabo: A Lamp for the Kingdom. Milan: Skira, 1997 — the founding, the paintings and the royal patronage
  6. Rizvi, Janet Trans-Himalayan Caravans: Merchant Princes and Peasant Traders in Ladakh. Oxford University Press, 1999 — on the trade that paid for monasteries

Last checked 2 November 2026 Yellowsea Huang Corrections