The mela ground at Pushkar is a dust bowl about a kilometre across, and for one week around Kartik Purnima it holds two entirely different economies at the same time. On one side there is a pen, and inside the pen there are camels. On the other side there is everything else: a Ferris wheel, a balloon, a craft bazaar, a stage, a cricket pitch, and a crowd that in 2024 was counted at six hundred and twenty thousand people, twenty thousand of them foreign.
The pen is where the fair's reputation comes from. It is also the part that is nearly gone. In the 1980s, herders brought thirty-five to forty thousand camels to Pushkar. In 2024 they brought fewer than five hundred.
A market is a meeting, not a commodity
The obvious prediction, when a fair loses ninety-nine per cent of its stock, is that the fair ends. It did not, and the reason is worth taking seriously: a market is not the thing it trades. It is a date on which a dispersed population agrees to be in one place. The commodity can change, and at Pushkar it did.
What the fair still sells, and sells more of every year, is the meeting: the camels decorated and judged, the turban competitions, the tug of war, the pot race, the folk troupes, the balloon. This is not a cynical substitution — the tourists were always part of the week, and a herder with fifty camels has always been paid partly in being looked at. But the ratio has inverted. The animals are now the decoration on a festival that is organised around the arrival of people who will not buy one.
The state's own arithmetic makes the inversion plain. In 2024 the fair recorded ₹11.83 crore of livestock sales across about eight thousand animals. Spread across the week and the crowd, that is roughly two hundred rupees per visitor in animal trade — against the gate, the stalls, the hotels, the balloon and the permits.
The law that shrank the herd
The camel did not decline because nobody wanted one. It declined because the economics of keeping one stopped closing. Rajasthan declared the camel its heritage animal in 2014, and in 2015 passed an Act restricting the transport of camels out of the state and their sale for slaughter. The intent was to stop cruelty. The effect, according to the herders and the organisations that work with them, was to remove the only cash exit a camel herd has.
The arithmetic is blunt. Half of all calves born are male. A breeding herd needs a handful of them. The rest have always been sold — as pack animals to other herders, or for meat — and that sale is what pays for the females, the fodder and the water. Close the exit and a male calf becomes a cost that never returns. A household that cannot sell its males cannot afford to keep its females, and the herd contracts from the inside.
The other side of the argument is not stupid, and it should be stated in its own terms: if a camel is not leaving Rajasthan to be slaughtered, what is it leaving for? The animal-welfare position is that the transport is the cruelty and the trade is the thing to end. Both sides are describing the same animal from opposite ends of its life. What is not in dispute is what happened next — the state's herd fell from 4.22 lakh in 2007 to 3.25 lakh in 2012 to 2.13 lakh in 2019, and India lost about three quarters of its camels in four decades.
What the fair sells now
Walk the ground and the hierarchy is visible in the prices. A camel sells for twenty-five to forty thousand rupees. A good Marwari horse sells for lakhs. The horses have replaced camels as the prestige animal of rural Rajasthan — they are faster, they photograph better, and unlike a camel they are not subject to a transport law. Buffaloes and cattle fill out the pens. The camel section, which is what every foreign photographer came for, is now the smallest part of the animal trade and the largest part of the image.
Around it, the festival has been rebuilt for the people who arrive by bus. There is a balloon that goes up for twenty minutes. There is a cricket match. There are stalls selling the same crafts as every other mela in the state, and a cultural programme in the evening. None of this is fake, and all of it is a different business from the one the ground was laid out for.
The uncomfortable part is who earns. A herder who brings fifty camels and sells three has paid for fodder, water and four days of his own time to stand in a dust bowl while a crowd photographs him. The money that the crowd spends goes to the municipality, the contractors, the hoteliers and the stallholders. Tourism revenue and pastoralist revenue are not the same revenue, even when they are standing in the same field.
What to watch
Go to the pen at four in the morning, before the crowd. The trading does not happen on a stage. Two men sit on a charpoy with a blanket over their hands and agree a price by touch, in silence, while the animal stands in front of them being looked at by a third man who has not said anything yet. It is the oldest part of the fair and the least photographed, because there is nothing to photograph.
Then look at the ages. Almost every camel on offer is between ten and thirty years old, out of a working life of forty to fifty. That is not a market clearing its stock; it is a market in which nobody is breeding replacements, because the replacement has no buyer. The pens are selling the last cohort, and they have been selling it for twenty years.
Sources and checks
- Mint, 2024 "In the 80s ... the famed Pushkar Camel Fair used to see a footfall of 35,000-40,000 camels. The 2024 count was less than 500" — Hanwant Singh Rathore, Lokhit Pashu-Palak Sansthan
- Scroll.in, 2024 20th Livestock Census: India's camels fell from about 11 lakh in the 1970s to 2.5 lakh in 2019, a 75% decline; Rajasthan 2.12 lakh, Gujarat 27,620
- The Federal, 2024 Rajasthan: 4,22,000 camels in 2007, 3,25,000 in 2012, 2,13,000 in 2019; camel prices of ₹25,000–40,000 against lakhs for a Marwari horse
- PTI, November 2024 more than six lakh visitors and 20,000 foreign tourists at the 2024 fair, the highest since 2019; animals worth ₹11.83 crore sold
- TravelBiz Monitor, November 2024 about 620,000 attendees and more than 8,000 head of livestock traded over the seven days
- Rajasthan Camel (Prohibition of Slaughter and Regulation of Temporary Migration or Export) Act, 2015 with the camel declared the state's heritage animal in 2014
Last checked 3 November 2026 Yellowsea Huang Corrections